From Coney Island Aquarium to Your Living Room: Rare Fish You Can Actually Keep

From Coney Island Aquarium to Your Living Room: Rare Fish You Can Actually Keep

If you grew up in New York, odds are you’ve visited the Coney Island Aquarium—a beloved staple for families, tourists, and ocean dreamers alike. It’s not the largest aquarium in the world, but it is one of the most iconic, blending urban grit with underwater wonder right on the Atlantic coast.

But here’s something most people never realize:

You don’t need a boardwalk pass or subway fare to recreate that sense of aquatic magic. With a well-thought-out tank setup and the right fish from RobsAquatics.com, you can channel the essence of Coney Island Aquarium—right in your home.

Whether you’re chasing nostalgia or just want a tank that wows, here’s how to build your own public-aquarium-inspired setup featuring rare freshwater species that take things beyond goldfish and guppies.

Why Coney Island Aquarium Sticks with Us

Located on Surf Avenue in Brooklyn, the Coney Island Aquarium has served generations since its 1957 debut. With its local fish tanks, interactive tide pools, and now-famous “Ocean Wonders: Sharks!” exhibit, the aquarium is less about being the biggest—and more about being yours.

It makes sense that many aquarium lovers cite it as their first inspiration. But you don’t have to stop at memories.

Let’s take what made Coney Island so charming—and elevate it with freshwater oddballs, catfish, and exotic species that give your home tank a serious upgrade.

8 Rare Fish That Bring the Coney Island Aquarium Vibe to Life

Each of these species is in stock now at RobsAquatics.com—perfect for your next tank project.

1. 🧡 Red Zebra Mbuna 4.5"

A bold, electric-orange African cichlid with attitude. Red Zebras add fast-paced motion and color to any tank, reminiscent of the energy you’d feel walking the aquarium’s freshwater exhibit halls.

2. 🌿 TWIG CATFISH (Farlowella)

The definition of oddball beauty. This skinny, stick-like bottom dweller looks more like driftwood than a fish—and that’s exactly the point. Place it among leaf litter or under driftwood and watch guests do double-takes.

3. đŸ›Ąïž Blue Ripsaw Catfish

Straight out of a prehistoric dream. This armored giant glides through your tank like a freshwater battleship, combining size, texture, and grace. Public aquarium vibes, shipped to your door.

4. 🐆 OTORONGO JAGUAR STINGRAY

Few fish match the exotic mystery of this freshwater stingray. With stunning jaguar patterns and an intelligent, curious demeanor, it mirrors the shark touch pool energy of Coney’s interactive exhibits—but for advanced hobbyists only.

5. 🐊 POLYTARUS PALMAS

Also known as the Senegal Bichir, this ancient fish glides like a slow reptile across your tank floor. It breathes air, has armored scales, and looks like something straight out of a dinosaur exhibit.

6. âšȘ CORYDORAS SCHWARTZI

Corydoras are the go-to community catfish, but this Schwartzi variant features fine-spotted patterns, reflective sheen, and peaceful behavior. Perfect for planted or mid-size displays.

7. đŸ”Č Black Pinoy Paraiba Angelfish

With silky-black fins and electric blue hints, this angelfish is a living sculpture. Just like the tall, slow-moving species featured in Coney Island's vertical tanks, these fish add grace and presence to your home display.

8. ⚫ VULTURE (MOTA) CATFISH

A mysterious, jet-black bottom dweller that adds drama to your tank’s lower layers. It’s rare, durable, and great for darker setups with hidden caves—ideal for night-themed aquascapes.

How to Bring the Coney Aquarium Feel into Your Own Tank

🎹 Aquarium Style: Urban Meets Underwater

Design a tank that feels both natural and nostalgic:

  • Use natural driftwood, New York–inspired stones, and vintage signage-style decor

  • Keep lighting soft and moody—just like the older aquarium halls

  • Feature species from multiple zones—bottom dwellers, gliders, and community swimmers

đŸ§± Size & Shape

  • A 75–125 gallon tank provides enough space for a “public display” feel

  • Taller tanks work great for angelfish and cichlids

  • Long tanks suit catfish, bichirs, and rays

⚙ Filters & Flow

  • Canister filters or sump systems keep water crystal clear

  • Gentle circulation helps bottom dwellers like twig catfish or Corydoras

  • Use sponge pre-filters for fry safety and delicate species

🌿 Tankmates & Community Planning

  • Avoid housing aggressive predators with delicate species

  • Build layers:

    • Surface: Angelfish

    • Midwater: Mbuna, Bichirs

    • Bottom: Corydoras, Mota Catfish, Stingrays

Why RobsAquatics.com Is the Best Store for Freshwater Showpieces

While Coney Island Aquarium captures our hearts, RobsAquatics.com captures your imagination.

đŸŽ„ Real Fish, Real Videos

We show the actual fish you’ll receive—no guessing or disappointment.

📩 Live Arrival Guarantee

Our shipping process is pro-level: insulated boxes, oxygenated bags, and the best temperature control in the business.

đŸ€ Personal Hobbyist Support

Questions? Get help before and after checkout. We’re not a faceless mega-retailer—we’re fish lovers just like you.

🔁 Weekly New Drops

Follow our YouTube channel to see what’s available now—including close-up previews of rare species like the Otorongo Jaguar Stingray.

Real Customer Reflection

“I used to go to Coney Island Aquarium every summer with my parents. I wanted to build a tank that captured that old-school wonder—but also had new, rare fish I could never find growing up. I got a Ripsaw Catfish and Black Pinoy Angelfish from Robs and I’m honestly blown away.”
— Danny M., Queens, NY

Conclusion: From Nostalgia to New School Aquariums

The Coney Island Aquarium will always hold a special place in aquarium history—but your home tank doesn’t have to play catch-up.

With the right mix of personality, rare species, and ambiance, your display can rival the exhibits that first got you hooked.

You’re not just building a tank—you’re telling a story.

🛒 Build Your Public Aquarium–Inspired Display:

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.